OUT FRONT
5
and respond to the ESG issues that are most relevant to
their business and their stakeholders. Firms with strong
performance managing relevant ESG issues achieve
superior market performance.
1
In order to do this, com-
panies often utilize materiality processes to identify
issues that are relevant or "material" to both their busi-
ness interests and key stakeholder groups. In the finan-
cial and accounting space, a matter is deemed material
for the purposes of financial disclosures if there is a
substantial likelihood that the judgment or decision
of a reasonable person might have been changed or
influenced by the inclusion or correction of the item.
2
In the corporate citizenship space, materiality takes on
a broader meaning to include non-financial elements
related to a company's ESG impacts or risks, generally
defined as issues that will inflence the decisions, actions,
and performance of an organization or its stakeholders.
Today there are multiple ways to disclose corporate
data and information that integrate aspects of financial
performance with ESG matters. Corporate reporters
often find the multiplicity of disclosure frameworks and
standards to be confusing. The introduction of TCFD
around climate-related risk initially added to this confu-
sion. To help ameliorate this, IIRC convened the Better
Alignment Project, a dialogue across reporting frame-
works, to help provide guidance for reporters struggling
with what and how to disclose in line with both TCFD
recommendations and with the frame-
works in use already.
A technical mapping exercise undertaken through
the Better Alignment Project showed that there is already
strong alignment among frameworks. Overall, 80%
of TCFD's 50 metrics are fully or reasonably covered
by CDP, GRI, and SASB indicators, with 70% of these
showing no substantive difference.
3
This is great news for
those responsible for corporate reporting because it sug-
gests a low barrier to entry in terms of TCFD adoption.
For 15 of the TCFD indicators, there are substantive
differences for certain industry sectors. This is where
companies will need to assess which frameworks make
most sense for them and decide how to approach their
disclosures. In this publication, we provide some guid-
ance to help those responsible for corporate reporting
navigate their disclosure choices via a more detailed
comparison of relevant indicators and their alignment
with TCFD.
TCFD-aligned reporting is rapidly becoming main-
stream. It is estimated that 1,100 large companies around
the world employ some form of TCFD-recommended
disclosure. This number is a small portion of the 43,000
companies listed on global exchanges and the hundreds
of millions of private companies established around
the world.
4
That number is sure to rise as the largest
investor networks in the world, representing some
$110 trillion in assets, have asked that their portfolio
companies begin aligning their portfolios with TCFD
recommendations and disclosing how they manage
for climate risk and opportunity in their investing.
5
•
1 The Boston College Center for Corporate Citizenship (2020). The
Business Case for Corporate Citizenship. https://ccc.bc.edu/content/
ccc/digital-knowledge-products/making-business-case-corporate-
citizenship.html
2 SEC Staff Accounting Bulletin 99. Securities and Exchange
Commission. https://www.sec.gov/interps/account/sab99.htm
3 Corporate Reporting Dialogue. (2019, September). Driving Alignment
in Climate-related Reporting: Year One of the Better Alignment
Project. https://corporatereportingdialogue.com/climatereport2019/
[Copyright © September 2019 by the Integrated Reporting
Foundation]
4 World Federation of Exchanges database. (2019) Listed domestic
companies, total. World Bank. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/
CM.MKT.LDOM.NO?most_recent_year_desc=false
5 The Investor Agenda. (2019, September). Progress Report.
https://theinvestoragenda.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/
IA-Annual-Report-2019.pdf